THE MAGNETIC FIELDS
LISNER AUDITORIUM – WASHINGTON, D.C.
OCTOBER 26, 2008
Stephen Merritt is notorious for depriving his fans of that which they most desire–to see The Magnetic Fields, one of indie-pop’s longest-lived and most eccentric bands, play live. The cantankerous genius recently told Indyweek.com, “Touring is traumatic for me and I try and suppress it. Live music is a mistake, and I regret my involvement with it.” Luckily for Magnetic Fields fans, Merritt briefly surrendered those insecurities this fall, when he and the band packed their bags for an American tour, stopping at Lisner Auditorium housed in our nation’s capital.
The Magnetic Fields began the night with their indelible stamp of bizarre humor. On “Walking My Gargoyle,” (from Merritt’s other band The Gothic Archies), his smooth baritone plunged to the lowest octave possible before causing involuntary face contortions. “Yes, everyone loves my little gargoyle,” he crooned… “I found him on a church, he helps with my research.” Next, Merritt serenaded fans with the story of a nun who dreams of becoming a porno starlet on “I Want To Be A Topless Waitress.” While these madcap lyrics are a trademark, their silliness doesn’t diminish a single note of merit from the band’s comprehensive sound. Shirley Simms’ frilly “tra-la-la” choruses on “Xavier Says” were an homage to Merritt’s Tin Pan Alley heroes Steven Sondheim and Irving Berlin, and a shining example of the classy, vintage sound that the Magnetic Fields inject into their music without sounding old-fashioned.
The band filled the entire stage, using all available space and looked like five small islands, alone and separated with their own talent and instruments, yet the plinky-sweet piano and cyclonic cello on “ Zombie Boy” (Distortion) brought them all together in a sweeping, sonic sandstorm. Sam Davol’s cello was deep and romantic on every song, especially “I Don’t Believe You,” but it was around this point that the absence of the Magnetic Fields’ signature synthesizers started to create gaps, each song sounding gradually more bare without their loopy, quirky accompaniment.
Singer/pianist Claudia Gonson abandoned her piano and stood alone for a gorgeous rendition of “Give Me Back My Dreams,” from Merritt’s band The 6ths (whose tongue twister band and album name, Hyacinths and Thistles is another example of his warped humor). Alas, “Yeah Oh Yeah” failed to deliver the desolate desperation from 69 Love Songs’ version. Merritt turned the should-be hopeless chorus into nagging, hyperbolic “nyah-nyahs,” foolishly ridiculing one of his saddest and most sadistic breakup songs.
When the band departed, playing the inevitable hard-to-get game, the audience was on their toes, anxious to hear their very special and personalized encore, the inevitable “Washington DC.” What they got was a half-assed a cappella version by an apathetic Gonson who barely remembered the words and gave up after one verse. It was a move that was weak and heartless enough to erase the previous twenty-six songs and all their glory. Audible audience gasps didn’t convince the band of a redo, and fans were left, mouths gaping at not only the band’s failed attempt, but their indifference at such a could-be-amazing moment.
So maybe Merritt’s quote about regretting his involvement with live music was some sort of self-fulfilled prophecy, or even just a way to veil his own very real insecurities. The Magnetic Fields certainly has the talent and endurance to deliver a truly amazing live performance, but sadly, he convinced us of how much he detests playing live. The Magnetic Fields just might be better appreciated on a record player, where one can play “Washington, DC” on a continuous loop for hours—the full version, that is.
–Lauren Pezzullo [November 10, 2008]




